Episode 59Jan 06, 2020

The Leadership X-Factor

John McGee
John McGee
The Leadership X-Factor image
Why is it that some organizations completely transform after a change in leadership? What is it that truly makes leaders stand out and instill confidence and trust? In today's episode, Adam and John discuss the leadership "X-Factor" and put practical terminology to this somewhat intangible concept. Ultimately, while God looks at heart, people inevitably look at outward appearance.

 

 

Episode Summary

But the LORD said to Samuel, “Do not look on his appearance or on the height of his stature, because I have rejected him. For the LORD sees not as man sees: man looks on the outward appearance, but the LORD looks on the heart.” - 1 Samuel 16:7

The Leadership X-Factor

Why is it that some organizations completely transform after a change in leadership? What is it that truly allows leaders to stand out and instill confidence and trust in their teams? Why do some leaders seem to have an "X-Factor"? The answer may be fairly simple. While a leader's character, competency, and substance are incredibly important and indeed the "permission-to-play" basics, leaders cannot forget that perception matters because we are ministering to people. Like 1 Samuel says that unlike God, people focus on the outward appearance, making snap judgments and forget to look any further. We would be remiss if we completely ignore issues of style, perception, or appearance. This leadership "X-Factor" will always be a combination of both substance and style. Growing in leadership will mean faithfully taking strides to improve both.

5 Characteristics for Self-Reflection

Here are 5 things to consider when questioning your own leadership style and how you are being perceived by others:
1. Appearance - Rapid judgments are a real thing. People are going to instantly form opinions the moment they meet you. Leading well may mean making changes to your appearance. This does not mean you need to focus on clothes, hairstyles, or shoes. Instead, ask yourself if there is anything in your appearance that might distract the people you lead.
2. Communication - How you communicate, both verbally and non-verbally matters. Tone and body language are incredibly important and make up a massive percentage of communication. Do you look engaged during meetings? Leaders will look attentive and ready to listen.
3. Decisiveness - No matter what role you play, there will always be opportunities to instill confidence by being decisive. Asking thoughtful questions and making guided decisions will always benefit the room. Don't be afraid to ask for time to process and be clear that you will indeed make a decision.
4. Emotions - The way a you regulate your emotions, both positive and negative emotions, weighs heavily into how you are perceived by others. When you are tempted to lash out, be angry, or fall to pessimism, you need to learn to manage yourself well. You cannot expect other people to manage your emotions. This might be as simple as taking a deep breath.
5. Energy - Leaders set the pace of the room. This, perhaps more than anything else, contributes to the "X-Factor" of a leader. It produces camaraderie and a desire to make decisions. When beginning a meeting, smile and greet people. You cannot allow whatever negative emotions you were feeling prior to entering the room affect how you lead in a group setting.

If you are in a position of leadership, give those you lead permission to give you feedback in each of these areas. Ask people how they perceive you and if your communication style, decisiveness, or energy level are being stumbling blocks to your effectiveness. Ultimately, you are ministering to people and wanting to lead them well. This means we have to understand perception and lead yourself well.

Referenced Resources

*Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman
*Decision Making Questions for Leaders Podcast
*Five More Bad Habits of Leaders
*Emotional Intelligence 2.0

Keep Exploring

Explore more articles and podcast episodes related to this topic.

Caitlin Sterlacci sitting at a table in the Watermark Community Church, Church Leadership Podcast studio speaking into mic.
Episode: 213Nov 11, 2026
10 Years of Leadership Lessons | John McGee and Caitlin Sterlacci

About this Episode After 10 years at Watermark Community Church, Caitlin Sterlacci has learned a few hard lessons. In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, she joins John McGee to reflect on her leadership journey, including: The leadership mistakes that changed how she manages her team. The hard feedback that helped her grow as a leader. The unexpected lessons God taught her through challenging seasons in ministry. From hiring decisions to leading through change, Caitlin shares practical wisdom she wishes she'd known sooner.

Church Leadership

Staff & Teams

John McGee sits in front of a mic and laptop in the Church Leadership Podcast studio at Watermark Community Church in Dallas, Texas
Episode: 212Oct 28, 2026
AI and the Church: 3 Questions for Church Leaders | John McGee

About this Episode AI is changing how people find answers, build relationships, and seek guidance. How can your church prepare? In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, John McGee shares three questions to help church leaders think beyond sermon prep and productivity: What will be scarce? What’s scary? And what’s possible? He explores the growing need for meaningful community and connection with God, the challenges AI could bring to the people you shepherd, and opportunities to free up resources for ministry. Through it all, he offers a reminder: Jesus still holds all things together. Listen in, then bring these three questions to your next team meeting.

Church Leadership

John McGee and Scott Kedersha of Watermark Community Church sitting at podcast table in front of microphone in podcast studio with blue graphic wall background.
Episode: 211Oct 15, 2026
The Trap of People-Pleasing | John McGee and Scott Kedersha

About this Episode In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, John McGee is joined by Scott Kedersha to discuss how people-pleasing affects church leaders. Scott shares how his desire for approval led him to overwork and compromise his convictions, while John reflects on his struggle with criticism of his work. They discuss how to recognize what drives the need for approval, have difficult conversations, and find rest in what Jesus has already done.

Church Leadership

Stay equipped

Keep up-to-date with news and updates on our latest podcast episodes, blog articles, and conferences by subscribing to our newsletter.