Episode 89Jun 30, 2021

Feedback: How to Give It, How to Receive It, and Why It Matters

John McGee
John McGee
Feedback: How to Give It, How to Receive It, and Why It Matters image
This special episode of the Church Leadership Podcast is part one of two on the topic of giving and receiving feedback. Enjoy this recording of Caitlin Van Wagoner and John McGee’s mainstage panel from CLC 2021 and additional discussion on why feedback is so important. For show notes and more, visit https://www.watermarkresources.com/clp/8443-feedback-part1.

 

 

Episode Summary

5 Principles for Giving Feedback:

  • Ask permission. No one likes to be blindsided by feedback. Asking for permission gives the other person an opportunity to be in the right mental state to receive the information you want to share.
  • Fight frustration. Proverbs 15:2 says, “The tongue of the wise commends knowledge, but the mouths of fools pour out folly.” Before giving feedback, note your emotional state and make sure you are not entering the conversation angry or upset.
  • Be specific. When giving feedback, generalizations will often be unhelpful. Instead, pinpoint specific areas where change needs to occur. If you don’t define a problem clearly, you cannot expect someone to respond effectively.
  • Make it actionable. Paint a picture of what success looks like. Use language like, “What if next time, you considered ….” This will help them not be lost as to what the future needs to entail.
  • Frame your feedback as an act of love and service. Proverbs 27:6 says, “Faithful are the wounds of a friend; profuse are the kisses of an enemy.” Communicate that the only reason you are sharing feedback is because you love and care for the other person.

5 Principles for Receiving Feedback:

  • Consistently ask for feedback. If you are someone who consistently and enthusiastically asks for feedback, not only will others be more likely to share with you, but you will also have more frequent opportunities to grow.
  • Fight defensiveness. If you are too defensive after receiving feedback, the feedback will often stop coming. People will be more hesitant to share with you.
  • Seek clarity. After initially receiving feedback, make sure to ask clarifying questions and clear up anything that doesn’t make sense. Perhaps even try paraphrasing back what you heard.
  • Try it on. Think about feedback like a piece of clothing you have the option to either keep or throw out. Trying it on first is the best way to come to that decision. Spend a few days applying the feedback to see if it does help. And remember, you do not have to absorb every piece of feedback.
  • Take a step towards them. The feedback giving and receiving process is a vulnerable one. After hearing what someone was brave enough to share, make sure to thank the other person for their feedback.

Keep Exploring

Explore more articles and podcast episodes related to this topic.

Caitlin Sterlacci sitting at a table in the Watermark Community Church, Church Leadership Podcast studio speaking into mic.
Episode: 213Nov 11, 2026
10 Years of Leadership Lessons | John McGee and Caitlin Sterlacci

About this Episode After 10 years at Watermark Community Church, Caitlin Sterlacci has learned a few hard lessons. In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, she joins John McGee to reflect on her leadership journey, including: The leadership mistakes that changed how she manages her team. The hard feedback that helped her grow as a leader. The unexpected lessons God taught her through challenging seasons in ministry. From hiring decisions to leading through change, Caitlin shares practical wisdom she wishes she'd known sooner.

Church Leadership

Staff & Teams

John McGee sits in front of a mic and laptop in the Church Leadership Podcast studio at Watermark Community Church in Dallas, Texas
Episode: 212Oct 28, 2026
AI and the Church: 3 Questions for Church Leaders | John McGee

About this Episode AI is changing how people find answers, build relationships, and seek guidance. How can your church prepare? In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, John McGee shares three questions to help church leaders think beyond sermon prep and productivity: What will be scarce? What’s scary? And what’s possible? He explores the growing need for meaningful community and connection with God, the challenges AI could bring to the people you shepherd, and opportunities to free up resources for ministry. Through it all, he offers a reminder: Jesus still holds all things together. Listen in, then bring these three questions to your next team meeting.

Church Leadership

John McGee and Scott Kedersha of Watermark Community Church sitting at podcast table in front of microphone in podcast studio with blue graphic wall background.
Episode: 211Oct 15, 2026
The Trap of People-Pleasing | John McGee and Scott Kedersha

About this Episode In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, John McGee is joined by Scott Kedersha to discuss how people-pleasing affects church leaders. Scott shares how his desire for approval led him to overwork and compromise his convictions, while John reflects on his struggle with criticism of his work. They discuss how to recognize what drives the need for approval, have difficult conversations, and find rest in what Jesus has already done.

Church Leadership

Stay equipped

Keep up-to-date with news and updates on our latest podcast episodes, blog articles, and conferences by subscribing to our newsletter.