Episode 90Jul 02, 2021

Feedback: What To Do When It Goes Wrong?

John McGee
John McGee
Feedback: What To Do When It Goes Wrong? image
This episode of the Church Leadership Podcast is part two on the topic of giving and receiving feedback. John McGee and Caitlin Van Wagoner discuss what to do when giving feedback goes poorly. Download the Principles For Feedback PDF Resource at https://watermarkresources.lpages.co/cpl-principles-for-feedback-resource

 

 

Episode Summary

5 Principles for When Feedback Goes Wrong

  • Recognize when conversation drifts. When the conversation you are having is not the conversation you intended to have, do not hesitate to pause or redirect the conversation back to your intended topic. As the giver of feedback, remember to not burden the person you are talking to with an overwhelming amount of feedback. Keep the main thing the main thing.
  • Don't be afraid to call a time out. If emotions rise or someone becomes frustrated, consider just taking a break, either for a few minutes or even a whole day. If someone grows too defensive, listening to feedback becomes an impossibility. Taking a time out can prevent fighting or divisiveness.
  • Widen the circle next time. If at first feedback goes poorly, the next time feedback needs to occur you can invite a neutral third party to help facilitate the conversation and translate between parties. Widening the circle needs to be telegraphed beforehand, but doing so can be helpful in righting wrongs. Make sure to not surprise someone by widening the circle unexpectedly or by only ever inviting those in positions of authority.
  • Make Sure You Resolve Relational Hurt. After difficult conversations or giving feedback, there will occasionally be times when significant relational hurt occurs and where this relational hurt impedes the working relationship. In these situations you need to prioritize making that relationship right. However, remember to play the long game. Understand that relational hurt is not immediately fixed and may require significant investment and intentionality.
  • Realize You Are Learning. Don't get discouraged when feedback goes poorly. Whatever the circumstance, you are going to learn more about yourself, the other person, and what to do better next time. Ask questions like, "What could I have done next time to make this process easier.

Keep Exploring

Explore more articles and podcast episodes related to this topic.

Caitlin Sterlacci sitting at a table in the Watermark Community Church, Church Leadership Podcast studio speaking into mic.
Episode: 213Nov 11, 2026
10 Years of Leadership Lessons | John McGee and Caitlin Sterlacci

About this Episode After 10 years at Watermark Community Church, Caitlin Sterlacci has learned a few hard lessons. In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, she joins John McGee to reflect on her leadership journey, including: The leadership mistakes that changed how she manages her team. The hard feedback that helped her grow as a leader. The unexpected lessons God taught her through challenging seasons in ministry. From hiring decisions to leading through change, Caitlin shares practical wisdom she wishes she'd known sooner.

Church Leadership

Staff & Teams

John McGee sits in front of a mic and laptop in the Church Leadership Podcast studio at Watermark Community Church in Dallas, Texas
Episode: 212Oct 28, 2026
AI and the Church: 3 Questions for Church Leaders | John McGee

About this Episode AI is changing how people find answers, build relationships, and seek guidance. How can your church prepare? In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, John McGee shares three questions to help church leaders think beyond sermon prep and productivity: What will be scarce? What’s scary? And what’s possible? He explores the growing need for meaningful community and connection with God, the challenges AI could bring to the people you shepherd, and opportunities to free up resources for ministry. Through it all, he offers a reminder: Jesus still holds all things together. Listen in, then bring these three questions to your next team meeting.

Church Leadership

John McGee and Scott Kedersha of Watermark Community Church sitting at podcast table in front of microphone in podcast studio with blue graphic wall background.
Episode: 211Oct 15, 2026
The Trap of People-Pleasing | John McGee and Scott Kedersha

About this Episode In this episode of Church Leadership Podcast, John McGee is joined by Scott Kedersha to discuss how people-pleasing affects church leaders. Scott shares how his desire for approval led him to overwork and compromise his convictions, while John reflects on his struggle with criticism of his work. They discuss how to recognize what drives the need for approval, have difficult conversations, and find rest in what Jesus has already done.

Church Leadership

Stay equipped

Keep up-to-date with news and updates on our latest podcast episodes, blog articles, and conferences by subscribing to our newsletter.